1. Health

Atkins Diet AND HCG -- Two Diets that Worked

Reader Reviews: Pros and Cons of the Human Chorionic Gonadotropin (HCG) Diet

User Rating 2 Star Rating

From Barbara

Updated July 23, 2010

This content is not monitored by About.com's Medical Review Board.
Before acting on this information, check with your health provider.

Diet Programs From the Thyroid Patient Perspective

Name of the Diet/Weight Loss Program or Service: 

Atkins/HCG

When did you follow this diet/weight loss program?: 

1997 and present

Website/URL:: 

http://www.atkins.com

My Review 

I lost weight successfully pretty much for the first time on Atkins in 1997 and kept if off for many years until a new thyroid crisis, after which I again gained. This time I was unable to lose even with Atkins. I contemplated lap band surgery, but ultimately realized that if you are not a big eater, lap bands may not be very effective. Gastric bypass would have done it, but came with too many risks and consequences. So finally I found the hcg diet online and researched it. Ultimately it is a 500-calorie very specific diet. The hcg doesn't make you lose more, but it does make that stringent diet much more comfortable and even positive an experience, and I seemed to lose weight from where I most needed it, rather than the usual wrong places. You do it only in four to six-week stints, and in between you readjust and learn to maintain that weight. The short periods make it easier than facing years of dieting. I have lost 55 pounds on it to date and am just beginning a new round.

Did you successfully lose weight on this diet? 

Yes

How much weight did you lose so far? 

51-100 lbs

Pros for Thyroid Patients? 

Both diets really help with energy and feelings of well-being.

Cons for Thyroid Patients? 

Any limitation sometimes is a hard pill to swallow. Make sure on Atkins to get your carbs mostly from vegetables. So-called Frankenfood is not a food group. Dr. Simeonton's diet requires a doctor's prescription and can be pricey.

Would you recommend this to a friend? 

Yes

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.