The Bigger Picture for Thyroid Patients
This is actually quite groundbreaking research, confirming in the research environment what
many patients, myself included, and some doctors, have been claiming for a number of years:
levothyroxine-only thyroid hormone replacement does not leave a substantial percentage of
hypothyroid patients feeling well, and these patients feel and function better when T3 is added to
their thyroid hormone replacement.
Interestingly, this offers an explanation for why patients have felt well all along on alternative thyroid
drugs like the natural Armour Thyroid, Westhroid and Naturethroid, which contain T4 and T3 naturally,
and the synthetic T4/T3 drug Thyrolar, which is the drug that I take. In some cases, patients also added
Cytomel (synthetic T3) or time-release T3 to standard levothyroxine therapy and also have better results.
For years, patients have been told that all they need is levothyroxine treatment to get them into
"normal TSH range," and thyroid treatment is considered complete. Time and time again, people
who still suffered with symptoms -- including fatigue, depression, cognitive problems, and more
-- were told that once their thyroid range was normal, these problems were no longer related to
the thyroid, and instead were now depression, stress, PMS, or simply "in your head." Patients
who had done well for years on Armour, then switched to Synthroid, for example, and
complained of not feeling well were told they were "getting old."
Consider this recent pronouncement in The Bridge, the quarterly newsletter from the
Thyroid Foundation of America, the organization that is supposed to be on the cutting edge of
patient issues and advocacy:
"TSH tests are very precise, and if your TSH is normal, then
thyroid dysfunction is not the cause of these symptoms."
Douglas Ross, Medical Advisor to the Thyroid Foundation of America
It's absolutely unconscionable that patients have been ignored, denigrated, overlooked, and
undertreated for as long as they have been by the conventional medical establishment, thyroid
organizations and medical groups.
Meanwhile, doctors who prescribed natural thyroid drugs like Armour -- or even its synthetic
counterpart Thyrolar -- were written off as quacks, or irresponsible, or in some cases, even
brought up on charges by the levothyroxine-only zealots in their local medical boards.
Let's hope that this information causes the patient and medical organizations, as well as the
doctor, to start listening more to patients -- and not to the pharmaceutical companies. Clearly, it's
been the marketing position of companies like Knoll Pharmaceutical, manufactuer of Synthroid,
that levothyroxine alone is all anyone needs. Following right behind and parroting every word
have been the hordes of endocrinologists who gladly benefit from Knoll and its competitors'
handouts of grant money, project funding, conference fees, and freebies galore, and are reluctant
to rock the levothyroxine money boat.
Leading the parade were fellows like Richard Guttler, who calls himself a "thyroidologist" and charges
patients a hefty $150 or more -- "required in advance" -- for his "Second Opinion" service on the
Internet. Last year, he kept angrily dismissing patients who
complained of unresolved symptoms and a desire to try these alternative drugs that are now
found to work better. Last year, a website reader wrote to him to let him know that the absence of
Synthroid after only three to four days relieved her of a persistent choking cough that she had
been enduring for the past twenty (or more) years. She told him that she'd changed to Armour. He
wrote back to her: "get a life! synthroid is not the cause of your problems." Last year, Guttler
also graced me with his unique brand of "bedside manner" (lack of proper capitalization and
punctuation is his):
"i'm glad all the "fringes" are filling up your e mail, not mine. it
makes my life easier dealing with only the mainstream thyroid patients who would never think
of taking armour or combo thyrolar or cytomel.what are you going to do when they finally take
thyrolar off the market? next it will be natural designer organic bathtub thyroid personally
brewed at your web site...dr.g"
Guess all the patients running fast as they can away from dinosaurs like "dr. g" will be running
toward the increasing number of "fringes" -- the astute, talented doctors who have listened to
patients, thought for themselves, forged ahead despite peer pressure and pharmaceutical company
marketing clout, all along practicing based on their knowledge that T3 drugs work better for
many of us. And those same doctors for so long condemned to the "fringes" are now proven right
by one of the very bastions of conventional medicine, the New England Journal of
Medicine

